Meat costs are up, however plant-based options nonetheless value extra

Meat substitutes are on common 38 per cent costlier than their animal counterparts, in response to a brand new report

Article content material

Fake meat has come a good distance since July 2018, when A&W turned the primary nationwide burger chain so as to add the Beyond Meat burger to its menu.

Advertisement 2

Article content material

“We’ve been at this for a while,” says Sylvain Charlebois, senior director of the Agri-Food Analytics Lab (AAL) at Dalhousie University. “The Beyond Burger was really the first disrupting campaign, which really upset the livestock industry.”

Nearly 4 years later, plant-based analogues are booming with extra choices than ever in grocery retailer meat sections.

Whatever the animal product — bacon, burgers, hen nuggets, fish or sausages — there’s a meatless equal. The expertise has superior to the purpose the place you could not even be capable to inform them aside, on the grill, range or desk.

Where you might be more likely to discover the distinction, although, is on the worth tag.

Even accounting for rising meat costs, plant-based substitutes are on common 38 per cent costlier than their animal counterparts, in response to a brand new AAL report.

Advertisement 3

Article content material

“After a few years, we thought that perhaps meat analogues would be priced competitively, especially in light of how (much) more expensive some meat products are now,” says Charlebois. “But that’s not the case at all. Which means that the bridge between analogues and other non-meat diets is still quite significant.”

Food costs elevated by 8.7 per cent in March, the most important year-over-year uptick since 2009. Charlebois predicts meals inflation could rise much more, probably reaching 9 or 10 per cent.

Over the previous 12 months, costs for beef, hen, pork and different meat merchandise have “increased dramatically”: 500 grams of bacon prices 17 per cent extra, for instance, one kilogram of pork chops 9 per cent and a one-kilogram blade roast 26 per cent.

Advertisement 4

Article content material

An openness to options can also be on the rise. According to AAL knowledge, 3.248 million Canadians determine as flexitarians (consuming principally vegetation, and infrequently meat and fish) — up 11.6 per cent since early 2021.

Meat prices up but plant-based alternatives still more expensive, study finds
Meat analogues are 38 per cent costlier than comparable, animal-based merchandise, a brand new Agri-Food Analytics Lab report discovered. Photo by Stefani Reynolds /AFP by way of Getty Images

Diets are dynamic, says Janet Music, AAL analysis program coordinator. So, it is smart {that a} routine named after its flexibility would resonate with folks.

“How you eat changes from season to season, maybe even from week to week,” she provides. “But I think these numbers show that if the vegetable analogue industry is really interested in changing people’s diets and changing people’s minds, they’re going to have to be more price-conscious to get more people to onboard.”

In its comparability of meat and plant-based substitutes, the AAL partnered with BetterCart Analytics, a Saskatoon-based software program firm that makes use of machine studying and synthetic intelligence to seize real-time grocery pricing knowledge, together with historic information.

Advertisement 5

Article content material

They collected multiple million costs (by weight) for 55 merchandise bought at Loblaws, Sobeys, Metro, Walmart and Save-on-Foods shops in 10 provinces from Jan. 1 to March 31.

For all classes however one, plant-based analogues had been costlier.

Chicken nuggets confirmed the best distinction in value between the plant and animal variations. Meals and entrees the second, and burger patties the third.

Turkey, doubtless because of its seasonality (the survey occurred after Thanksgiving and Christmas), is the one class the place the plant-based model was inexpensive.

“When BetterCart Analytics looked into this, I honestly thought this is it. This is the year. This is the time for plant-based products to shine and offer something affordable to Canadians,” says Charlebois. “But absolutely not.”

Advertisement 6

Article content material

Food affordability “is the big elephant in the room,” says Melanie Morrison, president and CEO of BetterCart Analytics. “For many consumers, especially right now, these products may be out of bounds. They may not be affordable enough for consumers to pick them up and give them a try.”

Prices are excessive generally, Morrison provides. But for meat substitute manufacturers — particularly newcomers — value might damage their skill to construct a buyer base. “When people look at products, if they’re too expensive and they’re not familiar with them, then those could be deterrents.”

Price influences folks’s meals selections, Music underscores. Rising costs and flexitarianism could have a optimistic correlation; as meals prices enhance, so may folks’s inclinations to eat extra plant-based merchandise — if it had been cheaper to take action.

Advertisement 7

Article content material

As the outcomes of the examine counsel, costlier meat substitutes might be value prohibitive.

“As unfortunate as it is right now, food affordability and pricing is just so critical for most consumers,” says Morrison. “And to get around it, I think it takes a special consumer. One that can actually say, ‘Okay, well, I’m going to make this decision here in the moment, but then I’m going to have to shift how I shop for the rest of my cart, potentially.’”

Advertisement 8

Article content material

Meat analogues provide comfort — at a price. But current research have proven that plant-heavy diets will be lighter on the pockets, and that consuming extra vegetation advantages the atmosphere.

A brand new examine within the Annual Review of Resource Economics by the University of Bonn means that, to satisfy local weather objectives, meat consumption should drop by no less than 75 per cent — particularly in industrialized nations.

The prevailing message, together with from Canada’s Food Guide, is to decide on plant sources of protein extra typically. The market, nonetheless, is saying one thing completely different, says Music.

“If plants are better for you — for the environment or for your health — then how come they’re not better for you in your pocketbook?”

While the report in contrast meat merchandise to their plant-based equivalents (i.e., merchandise, not diets), vegetable protein choices together with tofu and legumes corresponding to chickpeas and lentils current extra reasonably priced choices.

Advertisement 9

Article content material

“There are lots of ways to eat a vegetarian diet,” says Music. “And (meat analogues) is just one of those ways. But certainly, it’s a more expensive alternative to maybe just eating vegetables you grew in the garden or whole foods.”

Meat analogues have served the foodservice trade properly — particularly fast-food eating places — says Charlebois. Though retail, because the report suggests, is “a work in progress.”

In November 2021, Maple Leaf Foods introduced it was reviewing its plant-based technique after “cooling demand.” Charlebois suspects gross sales of analogues “are somewhat disappointing” generally.

Replicating the expertise of consuming meat is difficult and costly to fabricate.

The report, which is the primary of its sort to be launched to the general public, could act as an invite for meat analogue producers to analyze aggressive pricing, he provides.

“Thirty-eight per cent is quite substantial in light of what has happened to meat prices in recent years. And so, I do question the commitment towards the category, from the food retailer, specifically,” says Charlebois.

“If people are challenged by what’s going on at the meat counter, one would think that meat analogue manufacturers would see this as an opportunity to offer consumers an affordable, convenient solution. But that is absolutely not the case right now.”



Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We have enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail for those who obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a consumer you observe feedback. Visit our Community Guidelines for extra data and particulars on regulate your e-mail settings.

Source hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.